skip to main content
logo

McMaster Health Forum | Insights - Evaluate Innovations

 

Our evaluations have led to many insights about supporting evidence-informed decision-making. Here are our ‘top ten’ lessons learned:

  1. be clear about the goal;
  2. learn and use a systematic approach to analyzing priority issues;
  3. look for the right types of research evidence;
  4. look in the right places for research evidence;
  5. package the best available evidence in the right format and on the right timeline;
  6. use research evidence as the jumping-off point for citizen deliberations;
  7. use research evidence and citizen values as the jumping-off point for stakeholder deliberations;
  8. use the resulting story – evidence, values and insights – to drive change;
  9. make it the norm to use these types of inputs to drive change; and
  10. evaluate innovations in points 5-9 and make adjustments as needed.

In regards to lesson 1, here’s our preferred definition: evidence-informed decision-making means using the best available (data and) research evidence – systematically and transparently and in the time available – in each of: 1) prioritizing problems and understanding their causes (agenda setting); 2) deciding which option to pursue (policy or program development); 3) ensuring that the chosen option makes an optimal impact at acceptable cost (policy or program implementation); and 4) monitoring implementation and evaluating impact – alongside the institutional constraints, interest-group pressure, citizen values and other sources of ideas that influence the decision-making process. It’s long, but it covers all the bases.

For lessons 2-5, we’ve provided many key points on this summary sheet. For lesson 5, read more about our rapid syntheses, evidence briefs and citizen briefs. For lessons 6 and 7, read more about our citizen panels and stakeholder dialogues. And for lesson 9, read more about institutionalizing evidence-informed decision-making.

More from the Forum

Rapid evidence profiles addressing challenges related to COVID-19

To help health- and social-system leaders as they respond to unprecedented challenges related to the COVID-19 pandemic, the Forum has developed a new ... Read More

COVID-19 Evidence Network to support Decision-making

To help health- and social-system leaders as they respond to unprecedented challenges related to the COVID-19 pandemic, the COVID-19 Evidence Network ... Read More

Forum and OHRI teams prepare guide to COVID-19 evidence sources

To help OHT partners and other health- and social-system leaders as they respond to unprecedented challenges related to the COVID-19 pandemic, the For... Read More

COVID-19 update: Forum remains committed to supporting evidence- and values-informed policymaking about our health and social systems

In light of recent developments related to the COVID-19 pandemic, we have put in place measures to be responsive to inquiries from new or existing par... Read More

Changes to RISE activities due to COVID-19

The RISE team would like to provide an update on changes to our scheduled events over the next few weeks given the weekend’s developments with respect... Read More